The Safest Islands in the Caribbean and Ones to Avoid: A Comprehensive Guide

The Caribbean is a region of the Americas that consists of the Caribbean Sea, its islands and the surrounding coasts. It is a popular destination for travelers who are looking for sun, sand and sea. However, not all Caribbean islands are equally safe or suitable for every type of traveler. Some islands have higher crime rates, natural disasters, political instability or health risks than others. In this article, we will provide you with a comprehensive guide on the safest islands in the Caribbean and ones to avoid, based on various factors and sources. 

What makes an island safe? 

Safety is a relative and subjective concept that depends on many factors, such as: 

Crime rate

This refers to the frequency and severity of crimes that occur on an island, such as theft, robbery, assault, murder, kidnapping, etc. Crime rate can be influenced by factors such as poverty, inequality, unemployment, corruption, drug trafficking, gang activity, etc. Crime rate can affect both locals and tourists, especially in urban areas or tourist hotspots.

Political stability

This refers to the degree of peace and order that prevails on an island, such as the presence of a legitimate and effective government, respect for human rights and rule of law, absence of civil unrest or violence, etc. Political stability can be influenced by factors such as democracy, economy, social cohesion, external interference, etc. Political stability can affect both locals and tourists, especially in terms of security and access to services. 

Health care system

This refers to the quality and availability of medical services and facilities on an island, such as hospitals, clinics, pharmacies, doctors, nurses, etc. Health care system can be influenced by factors such as funding, infrastructure, education, technology, etc. Health care system can affect both locals and tourists, especially in terms of prevention and treatment of diseases and injuries. 

Natural disasters

This refers to the occurrence and impact of natural hazards that can affect an island, such as hurricanes, earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, floods, landslides, droughts, etc. Natural disasters can be influenced by factors such as geography, climate, environment, etc. Natural disasters can affect both locals and tourists, especially in terms of safety and recovery. 

Based on these factors, we have compiled a list of the safest islands in the Caribbean and ones to avoid, using reputable sources such as the U.S. Department of State Travel Advisories, the World Health Organization and the Global Peace Index. 

Read more articles about sailing, sailing tips and destinations in our Magazine.

What are the safest islands in the Caribbean? 

The safest islands in the Caribbean are those that have low crime rates, stable governments, good health care systems and minimal risk of natural disasters. Of course, safety is relative and subjective, and no place is completely risk-free. However, based on our research and reputable sources such as the U.S. Department of State Travel Advisories, the World Health Organization and the Global Peace Index, here are some of the safest islands in the Caribbean: 

• Anguilla: This British overseas territory is known for its pristine beaches, luxury resorts and friendly locals. It has a low crime rate and a high level of human development. It is also relatively free from hurricanes, earthquakes and volcanic activity. The U.S. Department of State has assigned Anguilla a Level 1 Travel Advisory, which means travelers should exercise normal precautions when visiting. 
• Barbados: This island nation is one of the most developed and prosperous in the Caribbean. It has a stable democracy, a strong economy and a high-quality health care system. It also has a low crime rate and a low risk of natural disasters. The U.S. Department of State has assigned Barbados a Level 1 Travel Advisory. 
• Cayman Islands: This British overseas territory is famous for its offshore banking, diving sites and wildlife attractions. It has a low crime rate and a high standard of living. It also has a low risk of hurricanes, earthquakes and volcanic activity. The U.S. Department of State has assigned Cayman Islands a Level 1 Travel Advisory. 
• Dominica: This island nation is known as the "Nature Island" of the Caribbean, due to its lush rainforests, waterfalls and hot springs. It has a low crime rate and a stable democracy. It also has a low risk of hurricanes, although it is prone to landslides and flooding. The U.S. Department of State has assigned Dominica a Level 1 Travel Advisory. 
• St. Barts: This French overseas collectivity is a favorite destination for celebrities and jet-setters, who enjoy its chic boutiques, gourmet restaurants and secluded beaches. It has a very low crime rate and a high level of human development. It also has a low risk of hurricanes, earthquakes and volcanic activity. The U.S. Department of State has assigned St. Barts a Level 1 Travel Advisory. 

What are the islands to avoid in the Caribbean? 

The islands to avoid in the Caribbean are those that have high crime rates, unstable governments, poor health care systems or high risk of natural disasters. Again, safety is relative and subjective, and no place is completely risk-free. However, based on our research and reputable sources such as the U.S. Department of State Travel Advisories, the World Health Organization and the Global Peace Index, here are some of the islands to avoid in the Caribbean: 

• Haiti: This island nation is one of the poorest and most troubled in the world. It suffers from political instability, social unrest, corruption, violence and human rights violations. It also faces frequent natural disasters such as earthquakes, hurricanes and cholera outbreaks. The U.S. Department of State has assigned Haiti a Level 4 Travel Advisory, which means travelers should not travel to this country due to very high levels of COVID-19. 
• Jamaica: This island nation is known for its reggae music, culture and cuisine, but also for its high crime rate, especially in urban areas such as Kingston and Montego Bay. It also faces social problems such as poverty, inequality and gang violence. The U.S. Department of State has assigned Jamaica a Level 3 Travel Advisory, which means travelers should reconsider travel to this country due to health and safety measures and COVID-19-related conditions. 
• Trinidad and Tobago: This island nation is rich in natural resources such as oil and gas, but also faces economic challenges such as inflation, unemployment and debt. It also has a high crime rate, especially related to drug trafficking, kidnapping and murder. It also faces environmental issues such as deforestation, pollution and climate change. The U.S. Department of State has assigned Trinidad and Tobago a Level 3 Travel Advisory. 
• Venezuela: This mainland country borders the Caribbean Sea on its northern coast, but it is not considered part of the Caribbean region by some definitions. However, it is included here because it affects some nearby islands such as Aruba, Bonaire and Curacao. Venezuela is undergoing a severe political, economic and humanitarian crisis that has resulted in widespread shortages of food, medicine, water and electricity. It also faces high levels of violence, corruption and human rights violations. The U.S. Department of State has assigned Venezuela a Level 4 Travel Advisory. 
• Puerto Rico: This U.S. territory is known for its diverse culture, history and natural beauty, but it also faces many challenges such as debt crisis, hurricane recovery, COVID-19 pandemic, and political status debate. It also has a moderate crime rate, especially in urban areas such as San Juan. The U.S. Department of State has assigned Puerto Rico a Level 2 Travel Advisory, which means travelers should exercise increased caution when visiting. 

How to choose the right island for your vacation? 

The right island for your vacation depends on your personal preferences, budget, travel style, and expectations. There is no one-size-fits-all answer, as each island has its own unique features, advantages, and disadvantages. However, here are some general tips to help you narrow down your options: 

• Consider your travel purpose: Are you looking for relaxation, romance, adventure, culture, or something else? Some islands are more suited for certain types of travelers than others. For example, if you want to relax on a secluded beach, you might prefer Anguilla or St. Barts over Jamaica or Puerto Rico. If you want to experience a vibrant culture, you might prefer Cuba or Barbados over Cayman Islands or Dominica. If you want to have an adventure, you might prefer Dominica or St. Lucia over Aruba or St. Martin. 
• Consider your travel budget: How much can you afford to spend on your trip? Some islands are more expensive than others, depending on factors such as accommodation, transportation, food, and activities. For example, if you are on a tight budget, you might prefer Dominican Republic or Grenada over St. Barts or Barbados. If you are willing to splurge on a luxury vacation, you might prefer St. Barts or Anguilla over Cuba or Haiti. 
• Consider your travel season: When do you plan to visit the Caribbean? Some islands are more affected by seasonal variations than others, such as weather, crowds, and prices. For example, if you want to avoid hurricane season, which runs from June to November, you might prefer Aruba or Bonaire over Puerto Rico or Dominica. If you want to avoid peak season, which runs from December to April, you might prefer Martinique or Guadeloupe over Bahamas or St. Martin. 

So what are you waiting for? Take a look at our range of charter boats and head to some of our favourite sailing destinations.